Thursday, September 18, 2008

Why Milk Matters to Journalism

This week I decided to focus on China. I have been reporting on China for many years and I'm always interested in how the U.S. media covers news events versus the way in which China's controlled media plays events.

The differences are particularly noticeable when it comes to informing the public about food safety. In China, issues of food safety aren't simply about health--they are about politics, about control, about maintaining stability.

I chose to look at the events surrounding a baby milk tainting scare that broke about a week ago in the press both in the U.S. and China. The facts as we know them are this: baby milk from SanLu, a major dairy brand in China, had been mixed with melamine, a plastic, that was causing kidney stones in infants. Three children have now died, depending on what news reports you listen to, and more than 1,000 have been sickened.

The China Daily article on the topic focuses primarily on the efforts the Ministry of Health has been taking to solve the problem. The story quotes from the Chinese Medical Association that no permanent damage will take place if the babies receive proper attention. The article attempts to divert attention from the fact that the Ministry of Health has moved slowly to deal with a problem that the company knew about months ago. But many people in China wouldn't know this if they only read the China Daily. If they had access to the New York Times or other foreign websites, they would learn that officials from New Zealand were blaming local Chines official for not taking action--until the New Zealand authorities got involved. Why is New Zealand interested? SanLu is owned in part by a New Zealand company.

Unlike the China Daily story, which only quotes from official Ministry of Health sources in China, the Times article quotes from the New Zealand government and media, as well as quotes from a Chinese official who had been to the area where the contaminated milk was found.

But the most interesting story about the SanLu milk scandal may be that the Chinese media that is not state controlled--there are few journalists who work outside the system at risk of their lives--are using the scandal to show off their journalistic prowess. This radio show from The World discusses how one Chinese journalist is taking on the state-controlled media. He is covering the SanLu story in-depth because as he says "this touches everyone from the richest to the poorest in China." He sees his role as one of disseminating information that will help parents take care of their children--not as necessarily opposing the government. But unlike the Times reporters, whose only risk is getting thrown out of China, this reporter could be thrown in jail for reporting the truth about a food safety scandal.

That's why milk matters to journalism--even the most seemingly innocuous stories can put journalists in other countries at risk. But increasingly in China, journalists believe it is their duty to serve the people--not necessarily the government.

No comments: